Thread Tools Display Modes
07/27/20, 08:56 AM   #1
Sharlikran
 
Sharlikran's Avatar
AddOn Author - Click to view addons
Join Date: Apr 2014
Posts: 692
Posting and Commenting Guidelines, Restrictions, and Responsibilities

Posting and Commenting Guidelines, Restrictions, and Responsibilities

I have not had time to completely outline every concern I have for mod author and user comments. A recent thread Current addon for porting settings? went from request to a unnecessary argument. It gave me something to think about.

Consider this a work in progress.

User responsibility

Users need to take responsibility for their actions. If users can not do so then they need to have posting privileges temporarily or permanently revoked or the user needs to be banned. Here are some examples.

- Users should read the site rules.
- Users need to be civil and avoid rhetorical, provocative, or inflammatory statements.
- Users should not claim mistreatment due to the answers they receive.
- Users should not act entitled to the authors' time, including posting comments in multiple places, bumping posts, or demanding immediate solutions.
- Users should not criticize the mod author if the author cannot reproduce an error and asks for more information.
- Users must accept responsibility for troubleshooting the mods they chose to install.
- Users should not get upset if a request is declined and should avoid posting critical comments about declined requests.
- You are not a lawyer, opinions are not defamation see below.

Rhetoric:

Rhetoric - language designed to have a persuasive or impressive effect on its audience, but often regarded as lacking in sincerity or meaningful content.
There is no place for rhetorical statements in our community. For example, comments like "this is what a helpful comment should look like" or snarky responses defending an entitled request do not benefit the conversation, mod request, or error report. These comments only serve to provoke and escalate tensions.

Users should not expect the community to fix or update mods on demand. Constructive feedback and genuine requests for help are welcome, but demanding behavior and disrespectful comments are not acceptable. Site admins should moderate such rhetoric, reminding users of the site rules.

Defamation

Sometimes conversations can include opinions, and people may be offended and use rhetoric to support their narrative, claiming they are victims of defamation. Users should not present opinions as legal facts, and site admins should not consider such claims valid.

Example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MB7dTDIEkdQ

Mod author responsibility:

- Remind users to post issues with relevant information, such as when the issue occurs and what actions were being performed.

Comment Moderation:

- Moderation of comments should be stricter to avoid clutter from issues caused by users not updating mods or installing requirements correctly.

If an issue cannot be reproduced, delete the post. If additional information is provided later, consider it a genuine issue and investigate further. If the issue still cannot be reproduced, inform the user that without a reproducible error, there is limited action that can be taken. Set the expectation that the post may be deleted if the user remains dissatisfied or if no further useful information is provided.

Reason for Deleting Posts:

- Deleting posts is not to be rude or disrespectful. Reproducible errors and their solutions are useful to everyone. Users can easily find and see resolved issues.
- Correctly installing and updating mods, and disabling conflicting ones, would prevent many error posts.
- Posts that do not provide useful information lead to repeated questions and waste users' time.

User Contributions:

- Mod authors can encourage users to create their own mods, look for existing mods with the desired features, or contribute code to the project.
- When a request is declined, users must understand and accept the response. Mod authors should not be verbally abused for declining requests. Users are not entitled to the authors' time.
- Creating a new mod out of spite because a request was declined is not appropriate. Duplicating an existing mod's functionality, even with different code, undermines the original author's work and can lead to unnecessary conflicts. Respect the author's decision and do not create redundant addons.

Last edited by Sharlikran : 07/29/24 at 09:54 AM.
  Reply With Quote
07/27/20, 09:18 AM   #2
Baertram
Super Moderator
 
Baertram's Avatar
WoWInterface Super Mod
AddOn Author - Click to view addons
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 5,187
I'd like to remember that addon devs are also users, so the same user rules would apply to them/us

what I would like to suggest is to start moderating your comments sections more strictly
I personally do not want to moderate the comments of addons I made or try to keep alive.
It's taking too much time to administrate or moderate. At least if you try to keep all "nice" and "with a good overview". I've learned this is not possible in forums, if you do not have anyone else doing this for you (having like a few hours a day to play, work on addons or just reading the forums).
I'll only delete comments that are off-topic, disturbing, or (in rare cases) are repeating the same questions just asked before (2 comments below e.g.).
You are free to handle this your way, but I'll just leave them in and follow the other way, described below:

As a kind of "best practice" which some addon authors already do:
I'd recommand the authors to write 1 comment, and ask Dolby to sticky this comment to their addon comments (as 1st comment, always shown).
Users/addon authors should read this as there you'll find current bugs, information, FAQ links etc.


But to tell the truth: Only less than the half, like 40%, will do so (even if it would be only 3 sentences) and click on links given there, answering their questions centralized.
The most just post another comment to "get their answer", no matter how often the same was asked or answered already.
It's a commonly spread way of forum interactions which I do not like at all, but it happens a lot.
Ppl just want to have a simple answer and a few do not even accept the "not possible" or "no", which you have mentioned should be very valid as well.

They should learn AND accpet that the world will not always bring personalized answers, without having to do anything for it.
We won't change this behaviour via addons nor comments nor moderating the threads.


And: I'd like to say thanks to the other ~60% of users/devs who do not behave this way! After all the community here is great and I like how it works.

Last edited by Baertram : 07/27/20 at 09:22 AM.
  Reply With Quote
07/27/20, 09:36 AM   #3
Sharlikran
 
Sharlikran's Avatar
AddOn Author - Click to view addons
Join Date: Apr 2014
Posts: 692
I personally do not want to moderate the comments of addons I made or try to keep alive.
Valid and it is a personal preference of mine. I'll see if I can reword it or replace it with something else.

I just don't want the post to be all "users need to" and not include some things that mod authors could do differently.
  Reply With Quote
07/27/20, 09:36 AM   #4
Sharlikran
 
Sharlikran's Avatar
AddOn Author - Click to view addons
Join Date: Apr 2014
Posts: 692
Also if this doesn't belong here in this section, please don't move it yet. I really have not thought everything through and it is in response to the thread mentioned which started in this section.

Last edited by Sharlikran : 07/27/20 at 10:39 AM.
  Reply With Quote
07/27/20, 10:41 AM   #5
Rhyono
AddOn Author - Click to view addons
Join Date: Sep 2016
Posts: 659
I might've missed it, but something that should be featured under the "user" section: users should put a modicum of effort into finding out whether their problem has been resolved/answered before. I've seen many examples of users posting for help when the answer is in a stickied comment. I've personally experienced a long chain of people posting the identical problem. Chain meaning literally all of the comments adjacent to their own was the same issue. When I warned that I would be deleting all future posts on the topic, users started taking offense to it that they shouldn't have to look through other comments first.
  Reply With Quote
07/27/20, 01:28 PM   #6
Sharlikran
 
Sharlikran's Avatar
AddOn Author - Click to view addons
Join Date: Apr 2014
Posts: 692
Originally Posted by Rhyono View Post
I might've missed it, but something that should be featured under the "user" section: users should put a modicum of effort into finding out whether their problem has been resolved/answered before. I've seen many examples of users posting for help when the answer is in a stickied comment. I've personally experienced a long chain of people posting the identical problem. Chain meaning literally all of the comments adjacent to their own was the same issue. When I warned that I would be deleting all future posts on the topic, users started taking offense to it that they shouldn't have to look through other comments first.
Users should not act as if the mod author is not helpful if the mod author can not reproduce the users error and asks for more information or steps to reproduce the error.
Thanks for the feedback that's covered. It is still a work in progress so I'll make sure as I writhe the short paragraphs for each bullet point and include something along those lines.
  Reply With Quote
07/27/20, 10:01 PM   #7
Dolgubon
 
Dolgubon's Avatar
AddOn Author - Click to view addons
Join Date: Jan 2016
Posts: 420
Originally Posted by Sharlikran View Post
However, what I would like to suggest is to start moderating your comments sections more strictly.
For some addons, this is feasible, for others, there's so many you just... give up, after a certain point, because there's so many. I've gone on strict moderating sprees, then I end up getting a bunch forget about it.
  Reply With Quote
07/28/20, 01:47 AM   #8
sirinsidiator
 
sirinsidiator's Avatar
AddOn Author - Click to view addons
Join Date: Apr 2014
Posts: 1,602
In my experience, there are two components to how many comments you will get. If your addon has a problem (even if you are not aware of it), you can rest assured that people will comment, even if they do not have the ability to express what is wrong and you'll have to do some detective work. And with problem I'm not just referring to bugs. An example:

What users comment: "Is there some way to close all tabs in AGS?"
Me: "No, but you can just middle click them to close one."
Me after seeing these comments show up again and again: "Why would you need something like that? You shouldn't have more than a couple tabs open"
Users: "The search by item feature opens a new tab for each search and I only check the price then switch back to the sell tab without closing them."
Me: "Ahhh."
At first it would just sound like they are entitled and want something new, but after spending a few minutes to put together a question and waiting for some answers I found out it's a real problem they have. I would never have thought of that use-case on my own, since I rarely use the search by item and if I had just ignored them, the comments asking for a close all tabs feature likely would have continued to crop up on a regular basis.

The other component is how much you engage with with an addon and its comment section. From my observations it appears if you upload too often (more than once a week) and answer individual comments, you will just get more comments in return, even if they don't tell you anything new or useful. For the past few years I tried to upload at most once a week and answer comments only in bulk every few days and leave snide remarks unanswered without deleting them.

It seems to work pretty well and I have deleted 0 comments in the past six years (although I do feel a need to vent on gitter from time to time ).

EDIT: There's also one other important thing I almost forgot to mention. Whenever I write answers to comments, I keep the proverb "What goes around, comes around." in mind and try to phrase my answer accordingly. If you want the users be respectful to you, you absolutely need to be respectful to them, even if their initial comment doesn't invite you to that. In that case it's always best to just keep some distance and let your emotions settle for a while before writing an answer.

Last edited by sirinsidiator : 07/28/20 at 01:54 AM.
  Reply With Quote
07/28/20, 07:36 AM   #9
Sharlikran
 
Sharlikran's Avatar
AddOn Author - Click to view addons
Join Date: Apr 2014
Posts: 692
Originally Posted by sirinsidiator View Post
EDIT: There's also one other important thing I almost forgot to mention. Whenever I write answers to comments, I keep the proverb "What goes around, comes around." in mind and try to phrase my answer accordingly. If you want the users be respectful to you, you absolutely need to be respectful to them, even if their initial comment doesn't invite you to that. In that case it's always best to just keep some distance and let your emotions settle for a while before writing an answer.
This is not the only part of your post that I like but I did want to bring attention to it. This is very good feedback. Thank you I will need to make some changes to my post and this has given me a few things to think about adding. Thank you.
  Reply With Quote

ESOUI » AddOns » AddOn Search/Requests » Posting and Commenting Guidelines, Restrictions, and Responsibilities


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off